“We did it!” – Their immortal legacy

a review by Julia Meredith

As we sat in the luminous interior of St James listening to the saga of its near-demolition, and salvation by Rodney Collenette, as recalled by his friend and collaborator Richard de la Rue, one nagging thought occupied my mind.
This extraordinary concert hall, which had attracted some of the world’s most renowned performers and seen the emergence of future superstars, came within a hair’s breadth – one single vote! – of being demolished to put up a police station. And I wondered… do we still have the commitment, the sheer donkey obstinacy in the face of bureaucratic pushback, to resist future threats to its existence?
The spirit that moved the small but heroic band to fight for its preservation for the people of Guernsey, was what this evening of reflection and remembrance hoped to celebrate.
Rodney Collenette was, for many people, the voice of Ebenezer le Page, GB Edward’s fictional Guernseyman who survived the Occupation and whose dry and pithy observations of Island life have never been bettered. In the course of an informal ‘fireside chat’ between Kate Rabey and Richard de la Rue, a picture emerged of the uphill battle to preserve what was essentially a beautiful wreck, nesting place of pigeons and through whose collapsed roof the stars could be seen. However it had one unique property, something no amount of decay could quite destroy: an exceptional acoustic, designed to carry a whisper from apse to vestry in the original church, and still ideal to transmit live music throughout the hall with no loss of quality.
To illustrate these superlative acoustics to States of Guernsey nay-sayers, Richard approached The Coull Quartet. They’d been conducting master classes at Elizabeth College, but at his request they crossed the road to St James, and in the dusty rubble they gave a recital to the committee. The quality of sound was enough to persuade the sceptics that St James was worth saving..
Returning to the present, it was a particular pleasure that the Quartet was there where it all began, to mark this 40th anniversary… though poignantly, without their much-loved second violinist and founder member Philip Gallaway, who died suddenly a month before.
Richard’s recollections helped to give an international perspective of St James’s architectural value. Famous artist and architect Sir Hugh Casson contributed a painting in support of the campaign, and Sir John Betjeman enthused in a letter that St James was ‘a focal point in the town’.
After the successful restoration, Yehudi Menhuin led the opening concert – but not before our own David le Page, violin prodigy, played Bruch on his 14th birthday, to an audience of schoolchildren. Some of those then-children were in the hall for this
concert, and mentioned how moving it felt to see that original vision of St James coming true.
If the aim was to show St James’s deep roots in Guernsey life, the readings from The Book of Ebenezer le Page, choice of Kate Rabey, were perfectly pitched to be both pungently local and simultaneously universal. This micro/macro quality, the ability to speak small truths which resonate worldwide, is part of the book’s international reputation.
Simon de la Rue’s delivery had the air of being unfiltered – unsentimental, but spoken from the heart. I thought his accent was spot-on (people with more right to judge than me, have agreed!) and he captured the impish quality of Ebenezer’s observations with a kind of earthy relish. ‘I had a good education, me’ was matched to the irrepressible energy of Alan Ridout’s Scherzo from Quartet no.3,
‘Crabbing’ and ‘Victor the Pup’ were linked with Frank Bridge idylls… the first, bustling and focused, showing the Coull’s perfect unity in their timing and dynamics, and for the more emotional second reading, subtle phrasing which added to the mood of wordless communication, a sixth sense between old friends.
So much intensity had to be packed into these short excerpts, to suggest the book’s astonishing depth of humanity. It was part of Rodney’s gift to make this believable to audiences – to ‘show Guernsey to itself’ – and I’d suggest that Simon shares something of this quality. We heard it in ‘Jim Mahy RIP’, which was read between Villa Lobos’s Brincadeira, full of optimism and direction, and then the heart twisting ‘Crisantemi’ written by Puccini on the death of a friend… expressing the heart-twisting pain of loss that Ebenezer also feels. Mine weren’t the only damp eyes, I know. I don’t think I’ve ever heard it more beautifully played.
Haydn’s Emperor Variations (the tune of the German national anthem) was tied to Ebenezer’s friendship with a young German soldier. It seemed to speak the truth of how individuals can rise above the constraints of seeing people as enemies and recognize what they share: a meeting of souls. In the hands of the Coull, ‘Deutshland Uber Alles’ became a joyous ode to harmony and understanding, infused with love and humility.
’A Guernsey joke’ was followed by Shostakovich’s Polka. This deliciously subversive romp, the music of a disruptor with a sense of humour, confounds expectation at every turn… not unlike our hero then, and a credit to the Quartet’s versatility.
The last reading, ‘Tcheerie’ closed the first half. It was fitting that Guernsey’s beloved Sarnia Cherie was given its premier in a new arrangement by local-born Angus MacRae. The intense charge of nostalgia it carried was like a view through a dimly-lit window into the past; a yearning vision of great tenderness.
After interval we were witness to one of those gifted young islanders, given their debut on St James’s magnificent Steinway as a stepping stone to an international career.
Tom Hicks, as most will know, is a concert pianist with a global reputation for magnificent pianism, performing in the UK, Europe and the United States. He set up
the Fanny Davies International Piano Series at St James, and his recordings are highly acclaimed: his Chopin Nocturnes earned him a Supersonic Award from Pizzicato, and his album of John Ireland and Tchaikovsky was selected for American Record Guide’s Critics’ Choice.
In short, we were lucky that his crowded schedule of performing, recording and teaching permitted an appearance on this evening – yet he packed so much richness and musicality into Dvorak’s Piano Quintet no 2 in A, we could not feel short-changed.
It was hard to believe how little time they’d had to rehearse beforehand. The musical relationship between soloist and quartet felt as though it had grown organically. The opening Allegro moved like a conversation between close friends as cello and piano launched into a passionate exchange, interspersed with gentler reflections. Yet the driving pace never lost this perfect equilibrium between instruments. All the more impressive when you consider that many of the Quartet have been playing together for decades – and with no more than a couple of hours to rehearse, Tom played as though born into the role.
The Dumka opens in a different mood: sombre, measured, sometimes described as a Slavonic lament. It was melancholy, but to my ears it seemed to spell out the importance of remembering, a relish in rehearsing old sorrows – and traditional joys too, as the folk-dance tunes burst through to impose their life-force in the midst of this musing.
The Scherzo was sheer delight. Wit and furious energy swirled through it, with changes of tempo which emphasized the intimacy of the Coull’s professional relationship. The tune was passed between instruments with generosity and respect; and while each added to the richness of the overall texture, the individual flashes of solo brilliance gave the whole a lustre that seemed to fill the air of St James with iridescence
Too soon, it was the Finale. Exuberant, triumphant, full of Czech folk tunes, it quickens the pulse, pulls you forward in your seat. The Coull played as though this music was the air they breathed – and seeing Tom dancing amongst them, never missing a note or a beat, and with such empathy for the performance as a whole, suddenly illuminated for me the deeper value of St James: this exquisite setting as an instrument, (like a Stradivarius?) lent to the most promising young musicians to give them the best possible chance of succeeding.

What a gift to the young stars of tomorrow! – and what an inheritance for everyone in Guernsey ready to make the most of this treasure on our doorstep.

Julia Meredith

Close
X

Forgot Password?

Join Us