Praise of Songs

an article by Julie Meredith

The Choir of Trinity College Cambridge, founded by Mary Tudor in 1546, arrived in the Channel Isles wreathed in history and acclaim.
When the prestigious classical music magazine Gramophone ranks a choir as the fifth best in the world, it can’t help raising expectations… while the sneaking sceptic in me prepares to be disappointed.
It hardly helped that the three choir members who were staying with us (imagine the logistics of finding thirty-plus performers a billet for the week! …let’s hear it for Guernsey hospitality) were such amusing, energetic, well-balanced individuals; hardly the obsessively competitive crew one might have imagined jockeying for a place in this elite ensemble.
Hence the anticipation levels for their first concert in St James; a stellar reputation to fulfil, a new(ish) conductor, in Steven Grahl, at the helm since early 2024, and the added challenge of integrating with Guernsey singers who had joined them that afternoon for a workshop, together with the Guernsey Youth Choir. In short, there were a lot of moving parts to reconcile.
Launching into the soundtrack of the week’s heatwave, Summer is icumen in was followed by early pieces by Weelkes and Gibbons, filling the air with a tapestry of intricate patterning. Notably through this lush interweaving of strands of harmony, specific parts were still clearly audible. Despite their snug integration, the voices kept pure and distinct within their courses, producing an almost 3-dimensional effect.
As the nerve centre of this refined and complex machine, the conductor is for me, the focal point of the ravishing sounds that the choir produces. Steven Grahl’s conducting style could have explained the music – without a note being sung. While understated, the repertoire of movements he used were precisely choreographed to the character of each piece. The St James concert of early madrigals and 20th century songs had a breezy buoyancy, and his style here – while never anything but restrained – had an impish jauntiness that made one beam in empathetic delight.
In the way a whisper makes you focus your attention, this less-is-more approach bound the choir to his direction with threads of silk. Their split-second timing,
the minute shifts in dynamic – and through it all, that perfection of pitch from every voice that welds a group of diverse individuals into a single instrument – all was flawless. And all without a score between them! Their hinterland of relentless rehearsing was there if you looked for it; but the illusion of a spontaneous outpouring of joy was complete in the moment it took wing.
Part of the Huanui Music Society and Guernsey Art’s objective in sponsoring Trinity College Choir’s tour, is to involve world class musicians in the musical education of the island. We saw the success of this in the inclusion of the Guernsey Youth Choir, led by Rachel Wright, singing separately and then with the Trinity College Choir.
It was an immensely impressive performance by the students and their conductor: their clarity and precision was exceptional. This was followed by a blending of the Trinity Choir with Guernsey singers, culminating in a magnificent roof-raising rendition of Hubert Parry’s ‘I was glad’… which really summed up how all those filling the warm air with their applause, felt about the whole unforgettable evening.
For nearly 480 years, members of this choir have been singing liturgy in the Trinity College Chapel several times each week, and it was their Town Church concert of sacred music that so many of us had been waiting to hear.
The programme had been put together with a thoughtfulness that gave us an insight into the remarkable versatility of this choir. From the medieval mysticism of Hildegard of Bingen, through the sumptuous harmonies of Tallis, Gibbons and Byrd, and on to the newer, sometimes disturbing sounds of Stanford, Herbert Howells, James MacMillan, Hubert Parry, Judith Weir and Cheryl Frances-Hoad, the fine-tuned talents of these choristers was on display. Their voices – all soloist-quality, to my ears – their accuracy, their sensitivity to direction and their ability to blend with one another; all was drawn forth and shaped by a conductor who evidently cares deeply; not just for the music, but for these young singers. Each visibly strives to follow his lead, as he strives to guide them towards perfection.
As a renowned organist in his own right, you could see how Steven Grahl used those skills to great effect – as though the choir itself were a myriad of organ pipes, stops and pedals that needed to be played with precision, timing and accuracy. His movements were unwasteful, focused and delicate, and the choir responds almost before his hands have moved.
In a programme too dense with delights to cover in detail, every piece, solemn or lighthearted, brought a frisson of pleasure. But there was one work that I felt showed the Choir or Trinity College as an almost superhuman entity, for their navigation of something ferociously complex – without loss of nerve, timing or tuning. This was Come Holy Ghost, by Jonathan Harvey, who died in 2012.
It opened with floating plainsong chant from a glorious bass voice, which hung in the nave glowing… and was gradually joined by crystalline young voices, which left space for the other harmonies to shine through, as through overlays of stained glass. Imperceptibly, the soundscape shifted and fragmented from unity into a shimmering cloud, atonal but exquisite in the same way a sky-ful of different birds singing their hearts out is uplifting.
This must be a terrifying piece to sing: how to find one’s note back home to the original pitch for the sublime unity of the final plainsong, defies imagination. The audience sat in a kind of dumbfounded awe for incalculable moments until we could breathe and return to earth once more.
A key element of the Choir’s style is the new-minted quality that they bring to even the most familiar pieces. There is a questing spirit that is not just building towards a predetermined vision of excellence: it feels as if each note is being determined in the moment of its creation, an elastic dynamism that relies on instantaneous recognition and response.
Grahl calls forth the deep sensitivity of each singer and sculpts it into something that resonates almost viscerally with the listener. To release that individual exposure, so the singers feel complete commitment to, and trust in their guide, is the ideal relationship of choirmaster and singers. And what a gift, for a conductor, to have access to some of the best voices around, eager to follow … it must be profoundly satisfying on both sides.
Town Church felt gilded by their singing, and the radiance followed us out into the evening air. This was music that speaks to the soul, and we felt blessed to have experienced it.
Julia Meredith

Close
X

Forgot Password?

Join Us